The risks of employees considering themselves overqualified: from tardiness to poor performance

Jane Anderson
Jane Anderson
Mujer descansando delante de una ventana con sol junto a su ordenador

Companies look for highly qualified professionals to shape their teams, but sometimes, they may end up occupying positions or performing tasks that do not quite fit their profiles. When employees feel that the functions they perform are below their level, that is, they consider that they are overqualified, friction can be generated that affects productivity and team management.

This is according to a study prepared by researchers from the hospitality management school at the University of Pennsylvania, and published on the scientific dissemination platform Science Direct. He has examined the relationship between employees’ perception of overqualification and perception of tasks as illegitimate, based on a scenario-based experiment and a multilevel field study.

The perception of overqualification

The researchers had 109 participants from the United States and the United Kingdom, all of them students and/or employees in various areas. They were presented with an exercise in which they held the position of hotel receptionist in two different cases: in one they had six years of supervisory experience and a master’s degree; in the other they had one year of experience and a high school diploma.

The possibility of considering a task inappropriate increases depending on the educational level and experience

They were asked to rate whether various tasks, such as staying in the lobby even without guests or manually transferring reports from old software to a new system, were reasonable based on their qualifications. The results showed that, with a higher level of education and experience, participants tended to consider the tasks as inappropriate for them.

In this sense, the analysis indicates that when employees perceive themselves as overqualified, they are more likely to consider part of their workload as unfair or useless. Furthermore, when they considered tasks to be unreasonable, that is, unfair to them as individuals but not so much a waste of time overall, they were more likely to have poor job performance and want to leave their jobs.

“Perception is what matters“explains Yoko M. Negoro, lead author of the study and doctorate in hotel management, according to the University of Pennsylvania. “If you feel like you are being asked to do something that is not up to your standards, this can negatively affect your attitude and work performance.“. He clarifies that the study focuses on how people feel, and not so much on trying to achieve an objective measure of what constitutes a legitimate task; and points out that the results can be extrapolated to any industry.

As the researchers explain, when a discrepancy is perceived between a person’s self-image as an employee and the tasks entrusted to them at work, said self-image can be affected. And to avoid feeling less successful or less valuable, professionals often mentally reject the task as a natural way to protect their ego.

Valuation as a solution

To confirm the hypothesis, the researchers verified the results in a real-world setting by surveying 225 employees from 46 restaurant chains in Beijing, China. The choice of this market responds to the fact that Asian cultures tend to have a more collectivist mentality, that is, individuals tend to prioritize the needs of the group over individual needs. Thus, by combining analyzes of Western and Eastern countries, it is established that, in all cultures, workers experience the same frustrations and feelings.

Unreasonable tasks were defined as those that employees believed they should not perform personally; and unnecessary ones like those they believed should not be done at all. Again, participants who felt overqualified were more likely to view tasks as unreasonable and unnecessary.

Unreasonable tasks are related to the intention to quit, tardiness or poor performance

Furthermore, it was found that while unnecessary tasks did not appear to increase negative behavior at work, unreasonable tasks were related to bad behaviors. Specifically, with the intention to resign, tardiness, lack of attendance, poor performance or carrying out personal tasks during working hours.

Despite everything, researchers point out that employers can influence employees’ perception of overqualification. According to the University of Pennsylvania, employees whose managers treated them with respect reported 28% fewer unreasonable tasks than those whose managers did not treat them with respect.

The authors suggest the periodic review of the processes and tasks assigned to each employee in order to determine their need, their value and their adaptation to the qualifications of each worker. They also explain that managers and business leaders can receive training to learn how to communicate the importance of the task.

Additionally, they encourage recognizing the contributions of each employee, especially in less desirable roles. This will lead to workers feeling more valued and, consequently, the perception that some tasks do not deserve the employee’s attention will decrease. In turn, respect could lead to a more productive work environment, with greater staff retention and more satisfied employees.